A Heart-of-Greenport-Village Home

210 5th Street
Greenport, New York

A 1934 three-bedroom in the heart of Greenport Village.
A few blocks to the harbor. A quarter-mile to the beach.

Scroll
210 5th Street · Greenport

A house in the middle of Greenport.

Three bedrooms and a bath and a half across 1,800 square feet, on a tree-shaded block in the heart of Greenport Village. Built in 1934, the house keeps the proportions and the bones of its era — coffered ceilings, light wood floors, big windows that look into the gardens, and a wraparound front porch with a full-size fireplace.

From the front door, it's three minutes to Front Street, four to the harbor, and a quarter-mile to the beach. Restaurants, the village green, the marina, and the Shelter Island ferry are all within reach without a car. It's the rare Greenport address you actually use — for the morning paper, the Saturday market, dinner out — instead of one you only drive to.

The block in spring is its own argument for the home: cherry trees fully in bloom, the village quiet enough to hear them. Across two stories there's space for a family or two couples; behind the house, a flat rear lot with room for a small in-ground pool. Offered at $1,350,000 by Douglas Elliman.

3
Bedrooms
1.5
Bathrooms
1,800
Square Feet
.16
Acres
1934
Year Built
2
Car Garage
Offered Exclusively by Douglas Elliman
$1,350,000.
Private & Public Showings by Appointment
Aerial of 210 5th Street, Greenport — three blocks to the harbor, a quarter-mile to the beach
Inside

Light wood floors,
coffered ceilings.

The living room runs the depth of the front of the house, with the kind of square-paneled ceiling and proportions 1934 still built into a Greenport home. Three sides of windows, light wood floors, a fireplace at one end.

Room by Room

A house that keeps it simple.

The dining room opens to the kitchen on one side and the front living room on the other. Upstairs, three bedrooms under sloped eaves and a half-bath tucked beneath the roofline.

Front living room with three sides of windows
Front Living Room
Dining room with rattan chairs and a pendant lantern
Dining Room
Dining room looking through to the living room
Dining · Through to Living Room
Upstairs bedroom under a sloped roof
Bedroom · Upstairs
The Front Porch

A wraparound porch,
with a fireplace.

The front of the house gives over an entire wraparound porch — a working fireplace at the far corner, white wicker chairs, a long railing that looks straight out into the cherry blossoms in spring and the harbor light in summer.

It's the room of the house that does the most work in May, June, September, October — coffee in the morning, drinks before dinner, neighbors stopping by on the way home from the market.

The Location

Everything is close.

The address is the thing. From the front door, the village, the harbor, and the beach are all within reach without a car.

¼ mile
To the Beach
Harbor beach & pier
3 min
To Front Street
Restaurants, shops, ferry
4 min
To the Harbor
Marina & Mitchell Park
90 min
To Manhattan
By LIRR · station 7 minutes
Greenport

A working village, not a resort.

Greenport is the easternmost village on the North Fork — a small year-round community that grew up around its harbor. Fishing fleet, ferry to Shelter Island, vineyards a short drive west, the Long Island Sound to the north and the bay to the south. The kind of place that earns its weekends.

A Short Block Away

The harbor & Front Street.

  • Mitchell Park & the carousel
  • Greenport Harbor Brewing Company
  • Claudio's & Crabby Jerry's
  • The Frisky Oyster, Industry Standard, Noah's
  • North Fork Roasting Co. — coffee in the morning
  • Shelter Island ferry · 5 minutes
By Bike or by Car

The wider North Fork.

  • Orient State Park · 12 minutes east
  • Cutchogue & Mattituck vineyards · 20–30 min
  • Macari, Bedell, Kontokosta · all under 30
  • Saturday farmer's market · Greenport
  • Oysterponds, Long Beach Bay, Truman's Beach
  • The Long Island Sound · north shore
Getting Here

From the city.

  • LIRR to Greenport · ~3 hours from Penn
  • Greenport station · 7 minutes by foot
  • Hampton Jitney · ~3 hours
  • By car · ~2 hours, traffic-free
  • JFK · 1.5 hours
  • Cross-Sound Ferry from New London · 80 min
The Neighborhood

Everything, within reach.

Restaurants, wineries, Sound and bay beaches, parks and marinas, farm stands, and the village — nearly all within a few miles of the front door. Tap a category, or any place, to explore it on the satellite map.

A Quarter-Mile Away

The harbor beach, on foot.

Out the door, down 5th Street, around the corner — a few minutes lands you on a soft sand beach looking out across Greenport Harbor. A long pier stretches into the bay. The water turns gold at the end of the day.

Bring the dog. Bring the coffee.

The Particulars

Specifications.

A summary of the property's hard facts. Full inspection summary and tax history available on request.

The House

Year Built1934
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms1 full · 1 half
Living Area1,800 sq ft
Stories2
Garage2-car
PoolRenderings on file

The Land & Records

Lot Size0.16 acres · 6,970 sq ft
VillageGreenport
TownTown of Southold
School DistrictGreenport UFSD
Annual Taxes$7,227
MLS#966420
List Price$1,350,000
A Vision for the Yard

Room for a quiet pool.

A flat, walled rear lot — the kind of yard a small in-ground pool sits naturally in. The renderings below are studies, not built work, sketched by an architect to show the scale and feel of what's possible behind the house. A starting point, not a constraint.

Architect's pool rendering — view from the lawn
Pool Study · From the Lawn
Architect's pool rendering — view from the patio
Pool Study · From the Terrace
The pier · 1/4 mile from the front door
Inquiries Welcome

A private showing of 210 5th Street.

Available by appointment. Reach out to either agent for the full property package, comparable sales analysis, or to arrange a private viewing.

Alexander Aquino
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Jill Dunbar
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Request a Showing